MagicReply is a Chrome extension that generates replies on X. Its Chrome Web Store listing describes a paid subscription and API-key setup. We could not verify the current subscription website on October 3, 2026 because Chrome blocked magicreply.io with a revoked-certificate error. Voxily drafts replies inside the reply box on X, LinkedIn and Reddit.
Free plan · No credit card · Desktop Chrome · Sign-in required
Human-reviewed drafting inside the social composer. No auto-posting. By Shuvo Anirban Roy, Voxily founder · Last verified:
Written by the maker of Voxily. Competitor facts are linked below; this is not an independent review.
MagicReply here means the Chrome extension “MagicReply - AI Replies for Twitter”, offered by MagicReply.io. It is not magicreply.ai, a separate site for AI replies to Google reviews. On our October 3, 2026 recheck, Chrome blocked magicreply.io with a revoked-certificate error. We did not bypass it, so we could not verify the current subscription website. The facts below come from its Chrome Web Store listing; “not stated in the listing” means the listing does not say. We have not installed or tested MagicReply. MagicReply is a trademark of its owner. Voxily is not affiliated with MagicReply.
| Criterion | Voxily | MagicReply |
|---|---|---|
| Platforms | X, LinkedIn and Reddit. | X, per its store listing title and description. Other platforms are not stated in the listing. |
| Where the draft appears | Inside the reply box on the post you are reading. | On x.com. The listing says to click Reply on a post, then press the star logo to generate a reply. |
| Voice inputs | A persona with tone, role, expertise and 2 to 5 of your own posts as writing examples, plus saved knowledge entries and eight moods. Pro adds Custom Mood. | Not stated in the listing. |
| Who posts | You. Voxily inserts the draft; you edit it and click the platform's own reply button. It never posts for you. | Not stated in the listing. The listing describes generating a reply after you click Reply. |
| Setup | Install the extension and sign in to a Voxily account. No API key. | The listing says to buy a subscription at magicreply.io, then paste the API key from magicreply.io into the extension. |
| Free plan | 10 replies a day, 1 persona, 5 knowledge entries and 8 moods. Account required, no card. | Not stated in the listing. The first setup step is buying a subscription, and the listing notes in-app purchases. |
| Paid price | Pro: $12.99/month or $120/year. | Not stated in the listing. The current price and subscription path could not be verified because Chrome blocked magicreply.io with a revoked-certificate error on October 3, 2026. |
| What else it includes | Post drafting, Fix My Reply and reply history. Pro adds Brand Mode, DM drafting and three reply options when enabled in Settings. | Not stated in the listing beyond reply generation on X. |
Sources: MagicReply on the Chrome Web Storemagicreply.io, checked October 3, 2026magicreply.ai, a separate review-reply productVoxily plans
Both plans include the eight standard moods, core drafting, history, and ratings.
| Feature | Free | Pro |
|---|---|---|
| Replies | 10 per day | Higher usage allowances |
| Personas / knowledge entries | 1 persona / 5 entries | Unlimited personas and entries |
| Post generations | 3 per day | Higher usage allowances |
| Chat requests / rewrites | 10 each per day | Higher usage allowances |
| Voice or import analyses | 3 per day | Higher usage allowances |
| Conversation length | 3 user messages per chat | No three-message limit |
| Fix My Reply | Included; uses reply allowance | Included; uses reply allowance |
| Three reply variations, Custom Mood, Brand Mode, DM drafts | Locked; opens pricing | Included; variations optional |
Here's how Voxily handles this workflow, and what you can check yourself in the extension.
Check the listing and the setup path before you pay for either tool.
One job: replies on X. You open a post on x.com, click Reply and press the star logo to generate a reply. Setup uses a subscription and an API key from magicreply.io. The listing does not state voice settings, a free plan or a price, so we do not compare those.
Voxily drafts in the reply box on X, LinkedIn and Reddit from a persona built on 2 to 5 of your own posts, with saved knowledge entries and eight moods. Free includes 10 replies a day with no card. You sign in instead of pasting an API key, and you always post the reply yourself.
Voxily drafts. You review, edit, and post the final text.
Open a post on X where you have a specific point, question or detail to add.
Install Voxily in desktop Chrome, sign in and add one persona with a few of your own posts. No card or API key is required.
Generate a draft in the reply box, cut anything you cannot back up and add your own detail. Then post it yourself.
If MagicReply still works for you on X, keep using it. Voxily does not import MagicReply settings or subscriptions.
Quick answers before you install.
No. magicreply.ai describes itself as an AI review response generator for Google reviews. The MagicReply compared here is the X reply extension whose store listing points to magicreply.io.
Yes. On October 3, 2026, its Chrome Web Store listing was live and showed a last update of November 5, 2024. On our recheck the same day, Chrome blocked magicreply.io with a revoked-certificate error. We could not verify the current subscription path or price. Check them before you buy.
No. You install the extension and sign in to a Voxily account. The Free plan includes 10 replies a day, one persona and five knowledge entries, with no card.
$12.99 a month or $120 a year. Pro removes the Free daily caps and adds unlimited personas and knowledge entries, Custom Mood, Brand Mode, DM drafting and three reply options when enabled in Settings.
Start with one real reply on X/Twitter, LinkedIn, or Reddit. Keep the draft only if it sounds like something you would actually post.
Install free