Voxily vs MagicReply

MagicReply Alternative for Reply Drafting on X (2026)

MagicReply is a Chrome extension that generates replies on X. Its Chrome Web Store listing describes a paid subscription and API-key setup. The subscription price and purchase path are unverified. Voxily drafts replies inside the reply box on X, LinkedIn, Threads, Reddit and Facebook.

Free plan · No credit card · Desktop Chrome · Sign-in required

Voxily X reply drafting interface Human-reviewed drafting inside the social composer. No auto-posting.

By Shuvo Anirban Roy, Voxily founder · Last verified:

Written by the maker of Voxily. Competitor facts are linked below; this is not an independent review.

Compare

Which workflow fits you?

This page compares the MagicReply Chrome extension for X. On November 20, 2026 its Chrome listing still pointed to magicreply.io for subscriptions. That domain redirected without exposing verifiable subscription terms.

Voxily and MagicReply: workflow and plan comparison
CriterionVoxilyMagicReply
PlatformsX (Twitter), LinkedIn, Threads, Reddit and Facebook in desktop Chrome. Threads and Facebook ask for site access the first time you turn them on.X, per its store listing title and description. Other platforms are not stated in the listing.
Where the draft appearsInside the reply box on the post you are reading.On x.com. The listing says to click Reply on a post, then press the star logo to generate a reply.
Voice inputsA persona with tone, role, expertise and 2 to 5 of your own posts as writing examples, plus saved knowledge entries and moods: Friendly and Professional on Free, all eight plus Custom Mood on Pro.Not stated in the listing.
Who postsYou. Voxily inserts the draft; you edit it and click the platform's own reply button. It never posts for you.Not stated in the listing. The listing describes generating a reply after you click Reply.
SetupInstall the extension and sign in to a Voxily account. No API key.The listing says to buy a subscription at magicreply.io, then paste the API key from magicreply.io into the extension.
Free planThe listed plan includes 3 AI replies per day, including Fix My Reply, and one post creation request per day for up to five platform drafts. Friendly and Professional moods, one persona and five knowledge entries. Sign in without a credit card or personal AI API key.Not stated in the listing. The first setup step is buying a subscription, and the listing notes in-app purchases.
Paid pricePro is $12.99/month or $120/year.The Store listing provides setup instructions. Current subscription access and price could not be verified.
What else it includes$12.99/month or $120/year. Pro includes unlimited replies and post drafts within fair use, unlimited personas and knowledge entries, all eight moods and custom tones, Brand Mode, DM drafts, three reply variations when enabled, Feed Queue with up to five drafts at once, and Follow-Up Tracker.Not stated in the listing beyond reply generation on X.

Sources: MagicReply on the Chrome Web Storemagicreply.ai, a separate review-reply productVoxily plans

Free or Pro

Start free. Upgrade when you need more.

Both plans include all five platforms, the Post Creator, Fix My Reply, duplicate-reply alerts, history and ratings. Free uses the Friendly and Professional moods. These are the Free allowances listed for Voxily 1.0.30. Check the extension for the daily limits in effect on your account.

Voxily plan differences
FeatureFreePro
Replies3 per dayUnlimited (fair use)
Post drafts1 per day (all platforms at once)Unlimited (fair use)
Chat3 requests per day, 3 messages per chatUnlimited (fair use)
Rewrites3 per dayUnlimited (fair use)
Voice checks (voice or import analyses and voice previews)3 per dayUnlimited (fair use)
MoodsFriendly, ProfessionalAll 8 + custom
Personas / knowledge entries1 persona / 5 entriesUnlimited personas and entries
Fix My ReplyIncluded; uses reply allowanceIncluded; uses reply allowance
Duplicate-reply alertsIncludedIncluded
Feed Queue, Follow-Up TrackerLocked; opens upgradeIncluded
Three reply variations, Custom Mood, Brand Mode, DM draftsLocked; opens upgradeIncluded
Use case

Why Voxily fits this workflow.

Here's how Voxily handles this workflow, and what you can check yourself in the extension.

Which one fits

Check the listing and the setup path before you pay for either tool.

  • Keep MagicReply if it is installed, your subscription and API key work, and you only reply on X.
  • Choose Voxily if you want a free plan to start, a sign-in instead of an API key, or drafts on LinkedIn, Threads, Reddit and Facebook as well as X.
  • Before buying MagicReply now, confirm the current way to subscribe. Its listing points to magicreply.io for subscriptions and API keys.

What the MagicReply listing describes

One job: replies on X. You open a post on x.com, click Reply and press the star logo to generate a reply. Setup uses a subscription and an API key from magicreply.io. The listing does not state voice settings, a free plan or a price, so we do not compare those.

What Voxily does differently

Voxily drafts in the reply box on X, LinkedIn, Threads, Reddit and Facebook from a persona built on 2 to 5 of your own posts, with saved knowledge entries and moods. Free includes 3 AI replies a day and the Friendly and Professional moods, with no card. You sign in instead of pasting an API key, and you always post the reply yourself.

Workflow

Draft, review and send a reply.

Voxily drafts. You review, edit, and post the final text.

01

Pick a reply you would write anyway

Open a post on X where you have a specific point, question or detail to add.

02

Try Free first

Install Voxily in desktop Chrome, sign in and add one persona with a few of your own posts. No card or API key is required.

03

Edit before you post

Generate a draft in the reply box, cut anything you cannot back up and add your own detail. Then post it yourself.

04

Keep what works

If MagicReply still works for you on X, keep using it. Voxily does not import MagicReply settings or subscriptions.

FAQ

Common questions.

Quick answers before you install.

Is MagicReply the same as magicreply.ai?

No. magicreply.ai describes itself as an AI review response generator for Google reviews. The MagicReply compared here is the X reply extension whose store listing points to magicreply.io.

Is the MagicReply extension still listed?

The Chrome Web Store listing was visible on November 20, 2026. Current subscription access and pricing could not be verified from the linked site.

Does Voxily need an API key?

No. You install the extension and sign in to a Voxily account. The Free plan includes 3 AI replies a day, one persona and five knowledge entries, with no card.

What does Voxily Pro cost?

$12.99/month or $120/year. Pro includes unlimited replies and post drafts within fair use, unlimited personas and knowledge entries, all eight moods and custom tones, Brand Mode, DM drafts, three reply variations when enabled, Feed Queue with up to five drafts at once, and Follow-Up Tracker.

Install Voxily and try it in one real thread.

Start with one real reply on X, LinkedIn, Threads, Reddit or Facebook. Keep the draft only if it sounds like something you would actually post.

Install free

Explore related workflows